Is it okay to discipline other people's kids?

Asked by Homall {104}
3/24/2010 1:29:40 PM

Being a divorced mother in a new relationship I have had this question come up quite a few times. My new partner has a daughter from a previous relationship. I also have two children of my own and we have one together. I have been in this relationship for 3 years and have not once disciplined her. I feel that I should not have a say in that nor do I want to be considered a bad guy to her. Am I doing the right thing? Or is there other ways to deal with this problem? Any help would be greatly apperciated!

Recommend this post on Facebook: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Tweet this post on Twitter: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Digg this post: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Share this post on StumbleUpon: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Share this post on Reddit: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Buzz up this post on Google: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Email this post to a friend: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids? Print this post: Is it okay to discipline other people's kids?
Flag as inappropriate
Answered by sarahjeanne {107}
3/24/2010 6:56:14 PM

[0 Votes]

Vote this up
Flag as inappropriate
There are several considerations here: how old is this daughter? And what exactly is the problem at hand- is she badly behaved? Disresepctful of you?In my experience before becoming a mom, every child that I have seen, especially those with bad behavior, are crying out for some sort of stability- they crave it from the moment they are born. Part of stability is discipline. Discipline does not have to be mean or hurt the child, but it does establish boundaries and reasonable expectations. (Ie: if you disrespect me, there are consequences). I feel you are doing a disservice to the daughter by not treating her as 'your child.' You are in a relationship with her parent that seems rather committed, so in essence there is a responsibility to her as another parent in her life. My husband and I have a housemate with a 3 year old girl and we regularly help with discipline. WE reinforce her mother's views and are a support network for the both of them to help her adjust to life only with her mommy (her parents are now divorced). IT's been a blessing for her to have those boundaries set and less of a headache for all of us, since she knows and can obey the rules of the house we have set forth as adults.Good luck in this- it's not easy to discipline but I think you will find a new sense of freedom and love once you take the initiative to establish yourself as a respected adult in her life. She doesn't need an adult 'friend'- she needs an adult who cares enough to see her at her very best.


Answered by georgiagin {246}
4/1/2010 1:34:18 PM

[0 Votes]

Vote this up
Flag as inappropriate
I feel you have a responsibility as an adult to help the child. Disciplining is simply helping them learn. It doesn't have to be a negative thing. As we all know, it takes a village to raise a child and we can all use some help from time to time. Since you've never done it before, anything you say will probably be listened to as something novel and will probably WORK. Imagine that!


Write your answer

2 Answers

0 Comments

182 Views

kids discipline relationship



GRAB MY BUTTON!



Related Questions

Does time out work for toddlers?

Good Age to Start Disciplining?

Discipline in children

Does your child ask you specific income questions?

Do you force meal times and eating?

Do you let your toddlers pick out their own clothes?

Best way to discipline a preschooler

Mom and Dad with different parenting styles

Appropriate punishments for a 5 year old

Appropriate punishments for a 5 year old

Does Your Child Have A Cell Phone

Am I a bad parent because I let my kids drink soda?

Punishing a child twice

NO MORE Arguing? What? How?

Anyone have tips for working at home with two young children?

When time out does not work

When is a child ready to help with daily chores?

Step-parent discipline?

What is the most dangerous thing for a high school child?

Tips for shopping with kids.

Sibling Rivalry-Who gets punished?

How can I stop my daughter from picking up bad habits?